De game heeft in totaal acht awards gewonnen, waaronder die van grootste innovatie van het jaar en voor zijn art direction en muziek. Adventuregame The Walking Dead heeft daarnaast ook vier awards gewonnen. De complete lijst van winnaars is hieronder te vinden.

Action Game of the Year: Borderlands 2
Mobile Game of the Year: Hero Academy
Handheld Game of the Year: Paper Mario Sticker Star
Outstanding Achievement in Original Music Composition: Journey
Outstanding Achievement in Sound Design: Journey
Outstanding Achievement in Story: The Walking Dead
Outstanding Character Performance: The Walking Dead: Lee Everett
Downloadable Game of the Year: The Walking Dead
Casual Game of the Year: Journey
Web Based Game of the Year: SimCity Social
Family Game of the Year: Skylanders Giants
Role-Playing/Massively Multiplayer Game of the Year: Mass Effect 3
Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year: XCOM: Enemy Unknown
Outstanding Innovation in Gaming: Journey
Sports Game of the Year: FIFA Soccer 13
Racing Game of the Year: Need for Speed Most Wanted
Fighting Game of the Year: PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale
Outstanding Achievement in Online Gameplay: Journey
Outstanding Achievement in Connectivity: Halo 4
Outstanding Achievement in Animation: Assassin's Creed III
Outstanding Achievement in Art Direction: Journey
Outstanding Achievement in Visual Engineering: Halo 4
Outstanding Achievement in Gameplay Engineering: XCOM: Enemy Unknown
Adventure Game of the Year: The Walking Dead
Outstanding Achievement in Game Direction: Journey
Game of the Year: Journey